When we talk about rebalancing a portfolio, one of the first questions we often hear is, “Do you think the market is about to go down?”
The answer is usually much less exciting.
We have no idea.
Rebalancing isn’t a prediction that stocks are about to fall, interest rates are about to move, or one part of the market has reached its peak. It’s simply the discipline of bringing a portfolio back in line with the strategy it was built around.
That can be surprisingly difficult when markets are doing well. When an investment has been climbing, the natural reaction is to leave it alone. Maybe it has further to run. Maybe we’re still early in the cycle. Maybe artificial intelligence stocks, large U.S. companies, or whatever is leading the market at the moment will continue outperforming for years.
They might.
But markets have a long history of changing leadership. And they rarely send investors a polite notification before it happens.
To Everything, There Is a Season
The song “Turn! Turn! Turn!,” made famous by The Byrds, borrowed almost entirely from the Book of Ecclesiastes:
“There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens.”
That idea happens to be a pretty good way to think about investing.
- There is a time for value stocks and a time for growth stocks.
- A time for international stocks and a time for U.S. stocks.
- A time for small companies and a time for large companies.
- A time for short-duration bonds and a time for longer-duration bonds.
- A time for emerging markets and a time for developed markets.
The problem is that we don’t know exactly when those seasons will change. For long stretches of time, one part of the market can dominate. Investors naturally begin to wonder why they own anything else. Then leadership shifts, often when few people expect it.
That uncertainty is exactly why diversification and rebalancing matter.
Rebalancing Is Not Market Timing
Suppose one part of your portfolio has performed exceptionally well. Over time, it grows from its intended allocation of 20% to 30%.
That might feel like a good problem to have. And in many ways, it is.
But it also means your portfolio has changed. You now have more money concentrated in one area of the market than your financial plan originally called for. If that investment falls sharply, the decline could have a larger impact on your overall portfolio.
Rebalancing means trimming investments that have grown beyond their target allocations and adding to areas that have fallen below theirs. In simple terms, you are periodically selling some of what has done well and buying some of what has lagged.
On paper, that sounds easy. Emotionally, it can be anything but.
“But What If It Keeps Going Up?”
This is where discipline comes in.
When an investment is doing well, selling any of it can feel like a mistake. Investors worry they are getting out too early. And they might be. Rebalancing does not guarantee that you will sell at the top or buy at the bottom. In fact, you almost certainly won’t.
That isn’t the goal.
The goal is to manage risk, maintain diversification, and keep your portfolio aligned with the financial plan you created before emotions and headlines entered the picture. Even when a long-term investment theme has significant potential, the road is unlikely to be smooth. Markets move through corrections, rallies, periods of enthusiasm, and periods of disappointment.
Rebalancing creates a process for navigating those changes without requiring you to predict them.
Rebalancing Is a Process, not a Prediction
The hardest part of investing is often accepting how much we cannot know. We don’t know when the market will decline, when growth stocks will give way to value stocks, or when international markets will outperform U.S. markets. We also don’t know exactly when today’s most exciting investments will experience their next correction.
A disciplined investment strategy doesn’t require those answers. Instead, rebalancing provides a systematic way to manage risk, maintain diversification, and take advantage of changing market conditions without pretending we can predict what happens next. There is a time to let investments grow, a time to trim positions that have become too large, and a time to add to areas of the market that have fallen behind. And every so often, there is simply a time to rebalance.
Wondering whether your portfolio still reflects the level of risk you intended to take? Approach Retirement Advisors can help you review your investment strategy, identify areas where market movements may have shifted your allocations, and determine whether it may be time to rebalance.
CLICK HERE to make an appointment.