Modern cars have some pretty impressive technology these days. They can warn you when you’re drifting out of your lane, alert you to another vehicle in your blind spot, and even brake for you when you’re getting too close to something.
But even with all that technology…you still have to decide where you’re going.
So, what does driver assistance have to do with tax planning? They can both help you avoid unnecessary costs, identify opportunities, and make the journey more efficient. But it shouldn’t be driving the car.
There’s an old saying in financial planning: Don’t let the tax tail wag the investment dog.
It’s good advice, but it doesn’t mean taxes should be ignored. Far from it. For investors with substantial assets, thoughtful tax management can make a meaningful difference in how much wealth they retain, spend, and ultimately pass on.
The trick is knowing when taxes should influence a decision and when they’re getting in the way of a better one.
Start With Your Goals, Not Your Tax Bill
Instead of asking, “How can I pay less in taxes?” start with, “What am I trying to accomplish and how can I do it tax-efficiently?”
That distinction matters. If you need to reduce investment risk, taxes should influence how you do it, not automatically stop you. If you’re preparing for retirement, minimizing this year’s taxes may be less valuable than creating flexibility for the years ahead.
The goal is to make your money support your life, not organize your life around avoiding taxes.
Roth Conversions: Paying Taxes Now Can Be Part of the Plan
A Roth conversion illustrates why a higher tax bill isn’t necessarily a bad outcome. Converting money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA generally creates taxable income now in exchange for the opportunity to take qualified withdrawals tax-free later.
A lower-income period early in retirement may offer an opportunity to convert some savings at a favorable tax rate. But the question isn’t just how much you can convert. It’s how much makes sense given your cash needs, how you’ll pay the tax, and your expectations for future tax rates.
Converting more isn’t automatically better. The strategy needs to fit the rest of your financial picture.
Concentrated Stock: Don’t Let Taxes Keep You Stuck
Let’s say a stock has performed so well that it now represents a large share of your portfolio. Selling would trigger capital gains taxes, so you keep holding it.
The tax bill is easy to see. The risk of having so much wealth tied to one company can feel less concrete.
Consider this hypothetical: If one stock represents $800,000 of a $1 million portfolio, a 25% decline in that stock would reduce your portfolio by $200,000, assuming everything else stayed unchanged.
That doesn’t mean you must sell everything immediately. Gradual sales may spread tax liabilities across years, although you’ll continue carrying some concentrated risk along the way. The right pace balances the cost of selling with the risk of waiting.
The bottom line is, sometimes paying taxes is the cost of moving toward a portfolio that better fits your needs.
Manage the Tax Cost Without Losing Sight of the Plan
Once you know what you want to accomplish, look for opportunities to make the decision more tax-efficient:
- Time gains thoughtfully. A lower-income year may be a useful time to sell appreciated investments. Holding an investment for more than a year generally qualifies it for long-term capital gains treatment—but waiting shouldn’t outweigh your cash needs or tolerance for risk.
- Use losses strategically. Capital losses can offset capital gains. When losses exceed gains, individuals can generally deduct up to $3,000 against other income annually, or $1,500 if married filing separately, and carry unused losses forward.
- Watch the wash-sale rule. Buying substantially identical securities within 30 days before or after a loss sale can disallow the current loss deduction.
Evaluate these moves together, too. A Roth conversion increases taxable income, which can affect the tax rate on long-term capital gains realized in the same year.
A Quick Gut Check
Before letting taxes drive a decision, ask:
- If selling had no tax consequences, would I still want this investment?
- What risk am I accepting by waiting?
- Am I focused on this year’s tax bill or my longer-term needs?
- Does this decision support something that matters to me?
Sure, give taxes an important role, but keep your goals in the driver’s seat. At Approach Retirement Advisors, we can help you put those objectives first and consider where tax strategies fit into your retirement plan. Schedule a conversation with our team to get started.